Should I get divorced? Questions to ask before you decide

Maybe you've been asking yourself this for months. Maybe it comes up late at night, or after the same fight for the hundredth time. Maybe you feel guilty even thinking it, especially if you have kids.

I'm Paul Walsh, a marriage and family therapist and a dad in Portland. I won't tell you whether to stay or go. That decision is yours. But I can offer some questions that help people think clearly, instead of deciding in the middle of a flood.

First, a few things that are normal

  • Going back and forth, sometimes in the same day

  • Feeling relief and grief at the same time

  • Worrying more about your kids than yourself

  • Feeling like you've already left emotionally, or like you're the only one trying

  • Not knowing who you'd be on the other side

None of that means you're making the wrong choice. It means it's a big one.

Questions to ask yourself

1. Is this a hard season or a hard pattern? Every marriage goes through rough stretches: a new baby, a move, a loss, a job change. Ask whether things were good before this season, or whether the same problems have been there for years.

2. Have we really tried, together? Not just talked, but actually tried something different, like couples therapy, with both of you engaged. If not, it can be worth knowing what's possible before deciding.

3. Do I feel safe? If you're afraid of your partner, or there's violence, control or threats, your safety comes first. That's a different situation, and it deserves its own support.

4. Is there still any warmth? Contempt, constant criticism and shutting down are hard on a marriage. But if there's still some fondness, some shared humor, some moments of being on the same team, there may be more to work with than it feels like.

5. What am I hoping will change? Is it something your partner could realistically change? Something you could change? Or something about the relationship itself?

6. Am I deciding from a calm place? Big decisions made in a flood of anger or exhaustion often look different a few weeks later. It's okay to slow down.

7. What would I tell a friend in my position? Sometimes we see our own situation more clearly through someone else's eyes.

8. What do I need to feel steady, whichever way I go? Support, a plan, a place to think. You don't have to have it all figured out to take the next small step.

What about the kids?

This is often the heaviest part. A few things that tend to help, either way:

  • Kids generally do better when conflict around them goes down, whether parents stay together or separate

  • How parents handle a separation often matters more than the separation itself

  • Kids benefit from hearing that it isn't their fault, and that both parents still love them

Staying steady for your kids while you're struggling is hard. You don't have to do it alone.

Individual counseling vs. couples therapy

If you're unsure, you have options:

  • Couples therapy if you both want to see whether things can change

  • Individual divorce counseling if you need a steady place to think, whether you're still deciding, in the middle of separating or rebuilding afterward

Neither one pushes you toward an answer. They give you clarity before you make a decision that's hard to undo.

If this sounds like you

Whether you're still deciding, separating or rebuilding, you deserve a place to think clearly and take care of yourself. I offer individual divorce counseling and couples therapy in person in Johns Landing, Portland, and online across Oregon, Washington and California.

Here's how I'll help: I'll help you think clearly before you make a decision that's hard to undo, and stay steady whichever way you go. You'll leave each session with one small step that doesn't feel too big.

Learn about divorce counseling · Learn about couples therapy · Book a free 15-minute call

This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for professional or legal advice. If you're in crisis or feel unsafe, call or text 988, or call 911.

Previous
Previous

How long does grief last? Why there’s no deadline